Stealing a line from Wil Wheaton, if all reboots were done this well, geeks wouldn't respond to reboots with the venom that they do.
For an old-school "lapsed catholic" Trekkie like myself, it was really a kick to see Trek given an actual A-List treatment (and budget).
My only real complaint about the movie was that it has, possibly, the worst astrophysics of any science fiction movie I've ever seen.
Also, it needed a Wil Wheaton cameo.